No edit summary |
Vhazhiphor (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 18: | Line 18: | ||
Do Worker golems really fit on this page? They aren't really a elemental force, but machines. --Timik |
Do Worker golems really fit on this page? They aren't really a elemental force, but machines. --Timik |
||
| + | |||
| + | ---- |
||
| + | |||
| + | I agree with Timik. Further proof is that the Golems seem to be weak to energy, whilst others in this category (like Gargoyles and Earth Elementals). So they're not earth-aligned. They're machines; not elementals. |
||
| + | |||
| + | [[User:Vhazhiphor|Vhazhiphor]] 22:26, 1 January 2009 (UTC) |
||
Revision as of 22:26, 1 January 2009
I was intedning this page to be specifically for rock style creatures - so I'm not sure is a geomancer would fit in. However if you feel it's worth of the page I have no objections. Also how do you feel about me moving plant-like "vegetable creatures" here - after all they come from the earth and seem enchanted.
Craggles
[Random::Chat::Guild::Contributions::Tibicam Profile]
About the geomancer, I have no idea what he/she* is doing on this page. Behemoths have nothing to do with earth. They are just a huge creature race like the Cyclopes. And if you want to include the plants you have to rename this page to Vego-Geo-Elementals or something like that.
*Yes, dwarven women has got beards so it could be a woman too
Art Featherpitch - The mispseller - Spam me 12:06, 9 June 2007 (PDT)
Destroyers, Behemoths do not belong here as they are not stone. The only thing they have relevant is the fact they can throw stones. However, this is not magical; they are just so strong that they are able to lift the ground and throw it. Geomancers don't belong here either, although they do have a slightly stronger case as they actually use magic and the knowledge of the earth to assist them. However, it was stated that learning about magic doesn't make it a magical creature, so they should be moved as well.
- Ryan
- Looked it up - turns out that Destroyers are demons and behmoths are hybrids of bulls...Doesn't that make them a form of minotaur?
- Also, they themselves may have no magical properties but the fact they are living and fighting when simply made of stone is magical. They have no organs, are enchanted and thus should stay under the magical section.
Craggles
[Random::Chat::Guild::Contributions::Tibicam Profile]
Do Worker golems really fit on this page? They aren't really a elemental force, but machines. --Timik
I agree with Timik. Further proof is that the Golems seem to be weak to energy, whilst others in this category (like Gargoyles and Earth Elementals). So they're not earth-aligned. They're machines; not elementals.
Vhazhiphor 22:26, 1 January 2009 (UTC)